Diet & Nutrition

Science says: Pot-hopping improves boiled eggs' texture and nutrition

Science says: Pot-hopping improves boiled eggs' texture and nutrition
It might not be simple, but you can have the perfect boiled egg by following the method revealed in a new study
It might not be simple, but you can have the perfect boiled egg by following the method revealed in a new study
View 1 Image
It might not be simple, but you can have the perfect boiled egg by following the method revealed in a new study
1/1
It might not be simple, but you can have the perfect boiled egg by following the method revealed in a new study

While Americans have been grappling with the high prices of eggs, Italian researchers have been looking at how best to cook them. They've derived the perfect method, although it might be too time consuming for the average home chef.

Eggs have certainly been in the news a lot lately. Most of that news has been economic in nature as the avian flu drives up their prices in the United States. But science has been taking a look at the incredible edible as well. Just this week, in fact, we reported on a study that found that eating one to six eggs per week lowered the risk of dying from cardiovascular disease by 29%.

Now, researchers from the University of Naples Federico II, and Italy's National Research Council, have applied the scientific method to eggs in another way: determining how best to boil them.

The issue with getting the perfect boiled egg is that the egg white and the egg yolk cook at different temperatures. The white, or albumen, cooks at 185 °F (85 °C), while the yolk cooks at the cooler temperature of 149 °F (65 °C).

To tackle this culinary conundrum, the researchers first used computational fluid dynamics software to model different cooking routines. Based upon those simulations, they settled on a cooking method: alternating between placing the eggs in water boiling at 212 °F (100 °C), which is the standard cooking temperature for boiling eggs, and then moving the eggs to a pot of water kept at 86 °F (30 °C). Moving the eggs back and forth every two minutes for a total of 32 minutes yielded what the team considered to be the "perfect" boiled egg.

Not only were the eggs cooked through this method – which the team dubbed "periodic cooking" – evaluated based on their texture and appeal to the senses, but they were also examined using nuclear mass resonance and high-resolution mass spectrometry. This deeper analysis revealed that during cooking, the temperature of the egg white ranged between 95 to 212 °F (35-100 °C), while the yolk remained at a steady temperature of about 153 °F (67 °C).

More interestingly, though, the chemical analysis found that eggs cooked through the periodic method, as opposed to more traditional methods, had a higher level of polyphenols in their yolks. Polyphenols are health-boosting plant compounds that are transported to chicken eggs through the hens' feed stock. They have been linked to everything from fighting cavities to warding off type 2 diabetes.

While the periodic cooking of eggs at home might be a step too far for most, the researchers say their work could have applications beyond better breakfasts.

"Overall, we found that our cooking method leads to improved texture and nutritional content with respect to traditional shell-on egg cooking techniques, thus elevating the already established concept by which temperature and time have a critical role in the resulting properties of egg parts," write the researchers in their study, which has just been published in the journal Communications Engineering. "The potential of this approach beyond cooking, with possible uses in curing, crystallization, and material structuring, is also foreseen."

Source: Springer Nature via Scimex

7 comments
7 comments
theradarsweep
The home cook can achieve a similar result simply by putting the eggs in a pan of cold water, bringing it to the boil and as soon as it reaches boiling point, removing the pan from the heat and letting it stand for about 5 minutes. White cooks in boiling/near boiling temps ; yolk cooks at a slightly lower temp.
Trylon
@theradarsweep, you don't know that the standing hot water method achieves "similar results" nutritionally with respect to the polyphenols.
Maybe this is a business opportunity for someone to create a campaign on Kickstarter for a device that can automatically shift eggs between two compartments of a temperature-controlled cooking vessel.
aksdad
Or fry them in butter, or make an omelet with a little ham, cheese, and onions, or whatever floats your boat, for the perfect texture and taste.
CDE
Who has time for this in the morning?
Karmudjun
Thanks for the synopsis Michael. It always helps to learn we have been doing something so basic in a nutritionally depleting manner. Are the shells easier to peel, or do they stick to the albumen (white of the egg as you noted in the third paragraph) and pull pieces of albumen with the shell? Are the yolks chalky and dry or are they moist and firm with the Italian Method? Easter is next on the holiday calendar and if there are eggs available, I need to boil about 4 dozen perfectly - help a scientist out with the answers, will you?
Uncle Rich
Who defines what a "perfect" boiled egg is? There's plenty of fun science in cooking, as regularly shown by America's Test Kitchen, but in the end, it's the more intangible elements that make a good egg. What were the chickens fed? How old are the eggs? How large are the eggs. And, most intangible of all, how do YOU like YOUR eggs cooked? Totally hard? Slightly jammy? Etc., etc. I guess there are reasons why this study was published in a journal called Communications Engineering, rather than is something more related to cooking and eating.
Christian
Cue all the nutrition influencers on tiktok and IG who are now going to tout this as the ONLY WAY TO EAT EGGS OR YOU'RE GONNA DIE! Those polyphenols, don't you dare destroy a few of them in the name of convenience!
Also, how much did this study cost to do, and who paid for it??